Last week we discussed the current state of EMV adoption in the United States. Today, more than a year past the original October 2015 liability shift, there is still plenty of work to be done. Confusion over the best course of action still lingers among some software developers and merchants. For many, the entire topic of EMV is disheartening. While market-ready solutions do exist (see Creditcall’s lineup of EMV Kernels and Payment Gateway Features), some companies are mired in integration challenges. Then, of course, there’s the certification process that can take months. In addition to these factors, there’s another trend affecting EMV adoption — chargebacks. At one time, chargebacks were an effective “stick” being used to hasten adoption. However, recent changes to chargeback rules might be playing a role in an EMV slowdown.
As the liability shift passed, merchants started getting hit with chargebacks over and above what they experienced in the past. Prior to the liability shift, issuers were able to detect probable fraud on disputed transactions, and — knowing they were liable for crediting the cardholder — they did not bother to process chargebacks. The issuers felt it would be a waste of time and money, as it’s very costly for them to process chargebacks in addition to the actual transaction loss itself. As a result, there were billions of dollars’ worth of fraudulent transactions not reported to merchants even though refunds were being issued to consumers. After the liability shift, the issuers had a valid business case to pass these chargebacks to the merchants.
One report estimated there have been 260.3 million chargebacks worth $5.8 billion so far this year, reflecting a 17 percent increase in transactions and 21 percent more dollar value than in 2015
Today, now that larger merchants have secured their payments infrastructure, SMBs are being targeted by criminals and fraudsters. One report estimated there have been 260.3 million chargebacks worth $5.8 billion so far this year, reflecting a 17 percent increase in transactions and 21 percent more dollar value than in 2015. Merchants have responded to this jump in chargebacks with lawsuits, which are expected to increase into 2017.
To ease frustrations, a few months ago Visa and Mastercard modified their policies to limit the number of chargebacks. The new and relaxed rules for chargebacks say that transactions less than $25 (corresponding to 40 percent of chargebacks and 15 percent of total chargeback value) cannot be included in the chargebacks, and they set a limit of max 10 transactions per card as a part of a chargeback.
We’ve seen some actual merchants that face tens of thousands of dollars in daily chargebacks. With the recent relaxation of the rules to no longer include amounts less than $25, chargebacks will be reduced but will still be very significant for many merchants.
Interestingly, this chargeback adjustment might have slowed down EMV adoption. Ingenico adjusted its growth number down and Verifone is showing a revenue decline last quarter. Both companies state that the relaxing of the chargeback rules has caused a slowdown in the deployment of new terminals. It’s possible that they are correct, but it’s also possible that their decline is due to an inventory buildup unrelated to chargeback rules.
It’s debatable whether chargebacks are an effective way to encourage EMV adoption or whether the rules adjustment is negatively affecting the rate of adoption. It’s unfortunate that we even have to discuss chargebacks when there are EMV solutions available today that can immediately address the needs of merchants. Software developers and merchants looking to address payment security quickly and painlessly can contact our offices to learn more. Take action today and let the card issuers and fraudsters focus on other merchants.
Insights from Lars Pedersen, Creditcall CEO.
Fill out the form below and we will get in touch with you shortly
The Generational Shift in Consumer Shopping Behaviors
With every generation, consumer behaviors change. Gen Z (ages 18-24) and Zillennial (25-26) shoppers grew up online. Many don’t remember a tim...Learn More
An Introduction to Payment Terms and Concepts
The payments space has a language all of its own. Who are acquirers? What’s a payment terminal? What about a PayFac? Whether you’re a new busi...Learn More
How NMI is Making 2023 the Best Year Yet for Our Partners
The payments industry has changed dramatically over the past several years. In 2020, consumer expectations shifted, and we saw a sudden rise i...Learn More
What You Need to Know About Buy Now, Pay Later Legislation
What if you could finance and pay for a purchase over time without a credit check or signing up for a personal loan? Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL)...Learn More
4 Steps to Make Your ISO Business More Profitable in 2023
As headlines warn of a potential recession, consumers are tightening their belts in preparation for a challenging year. While so much negative...Learn More
NMI Achieves Milestone Year in 2022 With Industry Recognition, Acquisitions and New Partnerships
Through acquisitions and continued platform investments, the company will continue to support partners from sign-up to pay-out across the comm...Learn More
The Evolution of Public Parking Payments
Parking payment solutions have evolved significantly since their inception. The first parking meters were installed in Oklahoma City in 1935 (...Learn More
The State of Public Transportation in the United States, the United Kingdom and Europe
'A developed country is not a place where the poor have cars. It's where the rich use public transportation.' - Gustavo Petro Public transpor...Learn More
Adding Value to Payment Solutions: 3 Ways to Generate More Revenue
Generating more revenue can be tricky - especially as consumers and businesses tighten their belts and cut back on spending. Should you add mo...Learn More
New NMI Report Finds Convenience and Speed Drive Consumers’ Eagerness to Try New Payments Innovations
SCHAUMBURG, IL – JANUARY 17, 2023 – NMI, a leading full commerce enablement technology company, today released its inaugural Payments Innovati...Learn More